Edition: U.S. | Arabic | Set Pref
December 11, 2008
Posted: 1318 GMT

The epic is a rare creature indeed in contemporary cinema. Which is a shame because, with the exception of the action blockbuster, it is the movie genre most suited to the big screen.

An inappropriately dressed Lady Sarah Ashley arrives in Darwin looking like she is ready for a couple of weeks on the French Riviera.
An inappropriately dressed Lady Sarah Ashley arrives in Darwin looking like she is ready for a couple of weeks on the French Riviera.

The latest director to step up to the dizzying task of producing one of these motion picture mammoths is Australian Baz Luhrmann.

Historical drama “Australia” is set , unsurprisingly, in Australia just before the outbreak of World War II. At something like $130 million it is the most expensive film in Australia’s history. Starring Nicole Kidman and Hugh Jackman, two of the country’s most famous Hollywood exports, the picture is an identifiably Australian epic.

With these credentials, it is no surprise 20th Century Fox, the studio behind the film, has been pushing hard for awards glory, although the film and its stars were absent from this week’s Golden Globe nominations.

Despite some pretty hysterical anticipation from fiercely patriotic Aussies, the film, which had a  lukewarm critical reception, has failed to perform that strongly at the box office in either Australia or the U.S.

Certainly, there is a lot to like. Nicole Kidman plays English aristocrat Lady Sarah Ashley — a winningly contradictory combination of uptight and feisty — who travels to Australia to her husband’s remote cattle ranch. A series of incidents throws her together with rough hewn Aussie bloke, Drover (played by Jackman and his impressive upper body musculature) and together they embark on an epic journey across Australia to save her land from a takeover plot.

As we have come to expect from Luhrmann, “Australia” is exquisitely visualized. The sets for Lady Sarah’s estate house are built in painstaking detail (there is even a tennis court) by Luhrmann’swife and long-time collaborator, Catherine Martin who had to transport everything to the remote East Kimberley region of Western Australia. Luhrmann shoots much of it in the magical dusk hours, showing the sets and the extraordinary landscape to their full advantage.

Kidman’s wardrobe is also a delight: the pith helmet, gauzed netting and strange wire spectacles she wears on her initial trip to “Faraway Downs” are fabulously OTT. They say more about her incongruousness in the dusty, gruff frontier land of 1930s Australia than 10 lines of dialogue — which can be cringingly cheesy at times.

It is here that “Australia” film falls down somewhat, for despite its technical brilliance, it doesn’t quite work. It could be because Lurhmann leaps from genre to genre — the Drover’s pub brawl at the start is pure spaghetti Western; at other times the narrative veers so far off into kitsch melodrama that you expect the characters to burst into song. All this to-ing and fro-ing undermines the dramatic punch, mainly because melodrama’s homely comforts sit uneasily on an epic canvas.

But, then what defines an epic?

In times past, they were easy to spot. They were historical films with a broad sweep like “Ben Hur” and “Lawrence of Arabia.” They dealt with big events in big landscapes and featured even bigger stars. An element of romance, or war, was often thrown in the mix too.

Although traditional epics are still made today, such as Ridley Scott’s “Gladiator” in 2000 and 2004’s “Troy” starring Brad Pitt, their massive budgets make them risky investments. Get it right like James Cameron did with “Titanic,” which was the first film to cross $1 billion in box-office receipts, and you have a work of massive prestige and profit.

Get it wrong and the result is Michael Cimino’s infamous 1980 Western “Heaven’s Gate” — now a byword for excess and perfectionism — that went so far over budget it almost bankrupted the studio, United Artists.

“Australia” certainly isn’t “Heaven’s Gate” and it probably won’t be “Titanic” either, but it is still a hugely visual film that, despite its flaws, still makes for a great cinema-going experience. Luhrmann should be congratulated for his work conserving this rare cinematic breed.

What’s your favorite epic movie?

Posted by: ,
Filed under: Behind the scenes • General


Share this on:
Amy C   December 12th, 2008 1229 GMT

Out of Africa!

Marc P   December 12th, 2008 1630 GMT

Excellent film – we need more like this.

Bee   December 12th, 2008 1705 GMT

Dances with Wolves is my favorite epic of all time. The music of a movie, especially ‘epic’ type movies, deserves more credit than it is often given.

Charles   December 12th, 2008 1738 GMT

Doctor Zhivago

Derrick   December 12th, 2008 1743 GMT

Ten Commandments – no doubt about it!

Robert   December 12th, 2008 1810 GMT

The Longest Day!

ivy o.   December 12th, 2008 1826 GMT

Out of Africa and The English Patient.

Steph   December 12th, 2008 1827 GMT

Gone with the Wind… It is a classic!!!

Andrew   December 12th, 2008 1930 GMT

“Lawrence of Arabia” is my favorite epic, though the made-for-TV “Masada” is very high on the list, and proof that you don’t need an astronomical budget.

uyioghosa   December 12th, 2008 1944 GMT

troy is my favourite epic,simply rivetting

Lynda   December 12th, 2008 1951 GMT

The Thornbirds

Poppie   December 12th, 2008 2011 GMT

“Giant” with Rock Hudson & James Dean

Margi   December 12th, 2008 2038 GMT

Gone with the Wind! with Doctor Zhivago being my second fav.

Olio   December 12th, 2008 2103 GMT

Lawrence of Arabia

Plan B   December 12th, 2008 2107 GMT

‘GIANT’

Barry   December 12th, 2008 2113 GMT

Ben Hur,Ten Commandments or Lord of the Rings all are great!

Kevin   December 12th, 2008 2125 GMT

Oh come on, it’s got to be Ben Hur!

Stephen   December 12th, 2008 2137 GMT

Lawrence of Arabia… from the well scene where we meet Omar Sharif this is one of the, if not the, best films of all time.

Robert in Adelaide   December 12th, 2008 2150 GMT

I found the movie formulaic and a tad disappointing… and I’m here down under. Most of my mates do not plan to see the movie. Unfortunately I did and I cringed at times.

Vinitha   December 12th, 2008 2155 GMT

Ben-Hur
Ten Commandments
Doctor Zhivago
Gone with the wind

Tom   December 12th, 2008 2259 GMT

Lord of the Rings…still blows me away…

JOHN   December 12th, 2008 2300 GMT

It is rare to have a film of the quality of Australia come to town. Shame to see all the criticisms. It’s beautiful story, with a great beginning, middle and finish. Great cinematography, great plot, great back drop, great acting, great music, and beautiful themes. It has a truly unique Aussie essense to it, in acting, in themes, in images, in sounds, and stories. I would see it again and again and love it. So far i have seen it twice. Any parent ought to be proud to take their child to see it. Apart from one F word, there is nothing offputting in it at all. Not saying another word. John

CS   December 12th, 2008 2329 GMT

Braveheart

COLIN   December 13th, 2008 015 GMT

I have considered any of David Lean’s work to be epics in their day: Bridge on the River Kwai; Dr. Zhivago; Lawrence of Arabia: Ryan’s Daughter……hard to pick between Zhivago and Lawrence. I’m off to see “Australia” this afternoon….being an Australian, I guess that I will cringe at some things, too.

Tommy D   December 13th, 2008 026 GMT

Ryans Daughter, From Here to Eternity, Doctor Zhivago, Once Upon A Time in America, A Bridge To Far

gazza   December 13th, 2008 027 GMT

whatacountry , great film ! should’ve used ben cousins!

fred   December 13th, 2008 040 GMT

it’s unconventional but i feel an epics none the less
mad mad mad world

Robert L   December 13th, 2008 129 GMT

SHOGUN…no more need be said.

Alainl   December 13th, 2008 156 GMT

Definitely David Lean’s Lawrence of Arabia. best epic movie of all time.

Paolo   December 13th, 2008 225 GMT

The Lord of the Rings

Jeff Costa Rica   December 13th, 2008 226 GMT

Spartacus. Films like that can no longer be made. Nowadays it’s all CGI which okay may appear as good but in your heart you know it’s all fakery.

David   December 13th, 2008 404 GMT

The Lord of the Rings. All 9 hours of it.

Krishna   December 13th, 2008 504 GMT

Gone With The Wind….the first one was the best one !

Kurt   December 13th, 2008 526 GMT

Being a military veteran, my favorite modern epics are Gladiator and Saving Private Ryan. But if you take away the influence of CGI, you really have to really appreciate the epics of the 1950s and 60s. The incredible cinemetography and musical score of Lawrence of Arabia make it my all-time favorite. Others in my DVD collection include Ben Hur, Spartacus, The Ten Commandments and The Greatest Story Ever Told. The beauty is when you couldn’t film in the deserts of Morocco or the plains of Madrid, the backdrops were hand-painted. If you needed a 5000-man army, you hired a cast of 5000. Again, no help from CGI. Also, Charleton Heston and Kirk Douglas were the absolute best of their era.

rbostrom   December 13th, 2008 536 GMT

Lonesome dove All time best

qw_t   December 13th, 2008 613 GMT

Would you consider Empire of the Sun or Legends of the Fall epic?? If so, they’re my favorites

Yeng   December 13th, 2008 714 GMT

Seven Years in Tibet, This epic movie took me so long to watch imagine 7 years … Kidding aside but one of the great movie that i ever watch

BRAVEHEART   December 13th, 2008 813 GMT

Breathtakingly beautiful

Ulyanov   December 13th, 2008 848 GMT

My 5 favorite epic movies for sheet spectacle are The Ten Commandments, Lawrence of Arabia, The Bridge on the River Kwai, Ben Hur and Doctor Zhivago.

willardT   December 13th, 2008 1150 GMT

The original Star Wars Trilogy. Way ahead of it’s time in so many ways

Rubens   December 13th, 2008 1152 GMT

Dr. Zhivago

Ricardo Campelo de Magalhães   December 13th, 2008 1207 GMT

Lord Of The Rings!

Clodya   December 13th, 2008 1220 GMT

Dances with Wolves…. so realistic to what we caucasians have done to a wpnderful, spiritual culture of the American Indians. It was about time a movie showed the truth about the real history of the domination and power that the white man hungered. They have literally wiped out some of the tribes that do not exist anymore.

The worst part is that these white men where suppose to be Christians?????

Makes one wonder.

Paulo A. Pereira   December 13th, 2008 1236 GMT

Lawrence of Arabia

Ann neilson   December 13th, 2008 1326 GMT

El Cid – fantastic movie!

Singapore Gooseman   December 13th, 2008 1413 GMT

BEN HUR – PERIOD!!!

Mihaela   December 13th, 2008 1417 GMT

Out of Africa

Marcel   December 13th, 2008 1422 GMT

The Last Emperor.
Lawrence of Arabia is still a favourite despite sir Alec Guinness trying to be a sjeik…
Another modern one is King Kong by Peter Jackson.

sue   December 13th, 2008 1443 GMT

Jewel in the Crown

mariatere   December 13th, 2008 1558 GMT

mis favoritas Out of Africa y Gladiador. buenisimas las dos.

shep   December 13th, 2008 1701 GMT

My vote…..”The Adventures of Bob & Doug McKenzie: Strange Brew”. It doesn’t get any more epic than this film. There’s alien invasions, a beer guzzling dog named “Hosehead”, and a spy thiller. The movie has it all! Australia, the movie, was dreadful. What a waste of potential greatness. The movie did have a musical feel to it. I too expected Huge to break out in song any time. Any Kidman, give me a break, what a terrible acting job, hopefully she makes good on her word and quits acting for mothering, and none too soon.

Hector   December 13th, 2008 1725 GMT

Ben-Hur.

Agatha   December 13th, 2008 1820 GMT

1900. Or Novecento as it is also known. Bertolucci’s undervalued master piece with great actors.

Gary   December 13th, 2008 1842 GMT

Gettysburg is a classic and it also has a great soundtrack… A Bridge to Far is also a personal favourite.

John   December 13th, 2008 1912 GMT

Dr Zhivago, El Cid, Ryans Daughter and Ben Hur

Haitham Fekry   December 13th, 2008 2055 GMT

Gone With The Wind bar none.

Jenny (Kiwi)   December 13th, 2008 2105 GMT

Legends of the Fall. I seem to be the only person who has actually watched it (many times over), it obviously wasn’t popular but I absolutely love it. Different strokes for different folks…………..Second has to be our very own Lord of the Rings of course!

Willem   December 13th, 2008 2130 GMT

I haven’t seen “Australia” yet, but your article was the first heads-up that this is a Baz Lurhmann project. In the North American markets, I think his name will draw more moviegoers, because on the surface, there doesn’t appear to be anything to pull ticket-buyers in (especially in an economic downturn) about a generically-named movie about a place and culture few people in N.A. feel any relevance towards.

I believe Lurhmann’s “Moulin Rouge” should qualify as an epic because the visual breadth and scope of it was a feast for the eyes, and the sonic landscape of the musical arrangements was a companion feast for the ears.

In my opinion, the only thing that kept it from winning Best Picture, was in its not knowing what kind of movie it was supposed to be. The balance of melodrama, comedy, campiness and musical theatre can be a very narrow tightrope to walk, and some of the campiness detracted from otherwise brilliant cinematography, staging, choreography and musical arranging. Perhaps “Australia”, from what I can surmise from the earlier comments, suffers from the same ambiguity.

An epic like “Titanic” was similarly flawed. In seeing it again last night on TNT, the cheesiness of the dialogue of the bearded fat guy and other dialogue on the research vessel really soiled the “hallowed” story which modern CGI technology was able to show us the realistic scale of. And one of the most poignant and powerful moments was the “tea orchestra’s” rendition of “Nearer My God To Thee” against the epic backdrop of this massive vessel and the scale of the humanity about to perish.

It was similar to the moment in another modern epic, “Schindler’s List”, where you follow a young boy to his tiny, hurriedly improvised, place of sanctuary in the midst of massive genocide . . . an outhouse “honey pot”. Sometimes an “epic’s” most powerful moments are in those scenes that don’t contain any dialogue. But nothing destroys an epic’s grandeur and credibility faster than poorly written dialogue.

A delicate brush on a wide-screen canvas can sometimes be an elusive feat, especially under the weighty revenue expectations of the financing studios. But the artist wielding the brush needs to have a clear sense of purpose and be able to balance all the ingredients (script, location, cinematography, CGI effects, music, costuming, choreography and so on) into a focused result. It’s a balance modern artists such as Spielberg, Peter Jackson, Coppola, and a few others have been able to achieve.

I hope it’s one Baz Luhrmaan comes closer to with “Australia” because “Moulin Rouge” was ALMOST perfect.

Willem   December 13th, 2008 2134 GMT

PS: It would also be a nice feature if you linked to the official websites of the movies you’re reviewing.

South Aussie bloke   December 13th, 2008 2308 GMT

1. The area on the map they point to as the location of faraway downs is in the lower section of NT, close to the border of SA.. NO CROCs in that location.. so the scene where the fellow was thrown in the river to be eaten by a crock…. rubbish…
2. Several Darwin bar scenes they play waltzing mathilda in the background… RUBBISH
3. Pack of roos that large running in outback.. uncommon
4. When she said crickey… god..

Sorry folks.. many of us down here in Aussie land HATE this movie.. and it embarasses us! I agree with the bloke above.. formulaic.. Nice for you yanks I reckon.. but its not the real Australia.. come down under and see for yourself! The real Oz is heaps better and more real (though we also cringe when you folks say “shrimp on the barbie”

-Cheers

Mel   December 13th, 2008 2321 GMT

1900!

Dana   December 13th, 2008 2338 GMT

Dr. Zhivago

Hal   December 13th, 2008 2340 GMT

El Cid, with Charleston Heston and Sofia Loren

Anita   December 13th, 2008 2341 GMT

Lawrence of Arabia

Vas   December 14th, 2008 002 GMT

The English Patient

Tambopaxi   December 14th, 2008 203 GMT

Lawrence of Arabia; definitely should see this on Blu-Ray w/ HDTV, it’s absolutely spectacular….

Ron   December 14th, 2008 232 GMT

Sibiriade (1979)

rama99   December 14th, 2008 331 GMT

Lawrence of Arabia, Dr Zhivago, Lord of the Rings, Sand Pebbles, jewel in the crown

DingBat   December 14th, 2008 711 GMT

Hey South Aussie bloke, you must have dozed off during the movie then. The character King Carney who ended up as a wildlife dinner snack, never left Darwin (where there ARE crocs) – he left his henchmen to do that.

As an Aussie, I won’t say that “Australia” is my all-time fav (LOTR would take that one) – but I didn’t want a refund afterwrds either!

marina   December 14th, 2008 737 GMT

the ONE and ONLY great: Gone with the Wind. Scores 10-10 whilst Australia scores a poor 3-10

zen   December 14th, 2008 923 GMT

GONE WITH THE WIND

Ray   December 14th, 2008 1153 GMT

Dr. Zhivago, How the West Was Won,El Cid

Dave Morris   December 14th, 2008 1328 GMT

I for one enoyed this film. As I watched it, thoughts of “epic” raced through my mind. It can be a little “Aussie cheesy” in places but all epics are.

Its just good to see a great movie that doesn’t explode in 60 seconds, land from another planet, have your heart racing at 200bpm or see’s the USA saving the planet again.

Refreshing & a big tourist plug for the guys down under

gail   December 14th, 2008 1714 GMT

Lots of beautiful scenery, and unique Australian humour – also lots of poor acting from King Carney and Fletcher (very unconvincing) – a mob of kangaroos in the middle of a dusty plain in the middle of the day would be EXTREMELY unlikely – they move at dusk and dawn and rest in the grassy shade in the daytime. I don’t understand why they didn’t use an English actress for the part of Sarah … Nicole’s english accent was not very believable. Also good acting, particularly from the Aboriginal actors. I’d give it a 5/10.

romeo   December 14th, 2008 1849 GMT

Gladiator

http://tinyurl.com/5koduv

doug   December 14th, 2008 1933 GMT

Apocalypse Now, extended directors cut. epic in the true sense maybe not, but certainly epic in production terms. and of course one of the best lines ever by robert duvall.

doug   December 14th, 2008 1938 GMT

and what about the french film, A Very Long Engagement. most expensive french movie ever made, beautifully shot and again centers on war and romance.

SeoJeong   December 15th, 2008 358 GMT

The pride and prejudice is my favorite epic.

paul gallico   December 15th, 2008 1721 GMT

Cant believe noones mentioned ‘the Last Emperor’ it was not only the best epic ever but no CGI, no cheesy dialogue, no cheesy holywood acting from so called stars and no typical holywood formulaic direction, just a brilliant performance all round from many hitherto unknown actors and actrices.

John   December 15th, 2008 2141 GMT

As an Aussie I felt duty bound to see Lurman’s “Australia”. In a nutshell this is an unabashed woman’s movie in the best of the Mills & Boon style. Take your face tissues because it milks the tears for all its worth. As a male, I won’t be going back to see it a second time.

I enjoyed the visual aspects. You can’t help being impressed by the sweeping grandeur of the Australian north west, but the schlock and jingoism had me squirming in my seat. Lurman takes some liberty with the historical accuracy of WW2 and Darwin, but hey! Hollywood made the distortion of history an artform.

Jackman and Kidman play credible roles, but the young aboriginal boy who goes by the name of “Nulla” is a refreshing face. This movie may not win any awards, but I suspect future DVD sales will help to recoup any losses at the box office.

blerkie   December 16th, 2008 441 GMT

Lawrence of Arabia and How the West was Won

Rainer   December 16th, 2008 616 GMT

The Ten Commandments, def!!!!

James Carter   December 16th, 2008 859 GMT

Weekend at Bernies

Mark   December 19th, 2008 1515 GMT

This movie was terrible. It was a Studio putting Big Names on a Markee and milking it for all it was worth.

Pat   December 19th, 2008 2140 GMT

Close encounters
http://tinyurl.com/48bqug
ndiana Jones

Julliy   December 24th, 2008 1948 GMT

Apocalypa now,,,,
http://tinyurl.com/7×32qq
Manhattan
E.T

Michelle   January 3rd, 2009 728 GMT

Princess Diaries or Harry Potter.
I love Tara Duncan, but it hasn’t made yet, I guess.

Cole   January 16th, 2009 1855 GMT

the concept of what makes an “epic” varies….but the common opinion that I see is that filming a period piece with a monster budget spent on 10,000 extras, props, orchestra soundtrack (don’t forget the violins) and a Caucasian protagonist (has to be Caucasian or people won’t take it as seriously) equates to an “EPIC FILM”.

What a load of crap! Thankfully more minorities (and the international community) are getting more of their stories out on film with better budgets…opening some people’s minds in the process…

Bernie   January 20th, 2009 857 GMT

A Passage to India
The Fall of the Roman Empire
Bridge on the River Kwai
The Great Escape
Samson and Delilah
Land of the Pharaohs
How the West was Won
55 Days at Peking

Leave Your Comment


 

Comments are moderated by CNN, in accordance with the CNN Comment Policy, and may not appear on this blog until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting. Also, due to the volume of comments we receive, not all comments will be posted.


subscribe RSS Icon
About this blog

The Screening Room brings you the inside track on all aspects of the movie business around the globe. Find out what goes on behind the scenes as we cover major film festivals and premieres and meet the directors and actors that matter.

subscribe RSS Icon
twitter
@cnnscreen: Gael Garcia Bernal/Diego Luna and the Mexican all-stars directors collaborate on "Rudo y Cursi:" http://tinyurl.com/nnysbo
Updated: Tue, 30 Jun 2009 14:28:53 +0000
Categories
CNN Comment Policy: CNN encourages you to add a comment to this discussion. You may not post any unlawful, threatening, defamatory, obscene, pornographic or other material that would violate the law. All comments should be relevant to the topic and remain respectful of other authors and commenters. You are solely responsible for your own comments, the consequences of posting those comments, and the consequences of any reliance by you on the comments of others. By submitting your comment, you hereby give CNN the right, but not the obligation, to post, air, edit, exhibit, telecast, cablecast, webcast, re-use, publish, reproduce, use, license, print, distribute or otherwise use your comment(s) and accompanying personal identifying and other information you provide via all forms of media now known or hereafter devised, worldwide, in perpetuity. CNN Privacy Statement.
Home  |  Asia  |  Europe  |  U.S.  |  World  |  World Business  |  Technology  |  Entertainment  |  World Sport  |  Travel
Podcasts  |  Blogs  |  CNN Mobile  |  RSS Feeds  |  Email Alerts  |  CNN Radio  |  Site Map
CNN en Espaňol  |  Arabic  |  Japanese  |  Korean  |  Turkish
CNN U.S.  |  CNN TV  |  CNN International  |  HLN  |  Transcripts
© 2009 Cable News Network. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by WordPress.com VIP